Durability + Design
Follow us on Twitter Follow us on LinkedIn Like us on Facebook Follow us on Instagram Visit the TPC Store
Search the site

 

D+D News

Main News Page


Final Order for ‘Zero VOC’ Claim Cases

Friday, March 8, 2013

More items for Coatings Technology

Comment | More

Settlement orders against two leading paint and coating companies for alleged false “zero VOC” claims are now final, according to the Federal Trade Commission.

The commission also released a new enforcement policy statement regarding VOC-free claims for architectural coatings, the FTC announced Wednesday (March 6).

The final orders came nearly five months after the FTC issued a proposed settlement with The Sherwin-Williams Company and PPG Architectural Finishes Inc. over allegations that the companies misled consumers to believe that some of their paints were free of volatile organic compounds (VOCs).

The FTC released the proposed consent orders on Oct. 25 and solicited public comment until Nov. 26.

Sherwin Williams
Sherwin-Williams

Both companies are banned from claiming their paints contain "zero VOCs," unless the products have zero VOCs after tinting or the companies can prove the claim with scientific evidence.

Consent Order Details

In settling the FTC complaints, the companies agreed to consent orders that forbid them from claiming that Sherwin-Williams’ Dutch Boy Refresh and PPG’s Pure Performance interior paints, respectively, contain “zero” VOCs.

The orders are the same for both PPG and Sherwin-Williams and carry no fines.

The orders “prohibit the companies from claiming that their paints contain ‘zero VOCs,’ unless, after tinting, they have a VOC level of zero grams per liter, or the companies have competent and reliable scientific evidence that the paint contains no more than trace levels of VOCs,” according to the FTC.

The companies must "clearly and prominently disclose that the ‘zero VOC’ claims apply only to the base paint, and that depending on the consumer’s color choice, the VOC level may rise,” the agency said.

Sherwin Williams Dutch Boy Paint PPG
(Left) Sherwin Williams; (Right) PPG Pittsburgh Paints

FTC said Sherwin Williams' and PPG's claims on Dutch Boy Refresh and Pure Performance interior paints, respectively, were misleading. The companies said they were implementing new practices to comply.

In cases where the tinted paint’s VOC level could be 50 grams per liter or more, the companies must disclose that the VOC level may increase “significantly” or “up to [the highest possible VOC level after tinting].” 

While the “zero VOC” claim may be true for uncolored base paints, it is not true for tinted products, which typically have much higher VOC levels and are more frequently purchased by consumers, FTC said.

The orders also prohibit both the companies from providing anyone—including independent retailers and distributors—with the means of making any of the prohibited deceptive claims.

The FTC vote approving the final order and a letter to a member of the public who commented on it was 3-0-2, with Commissioners Jon Leibowitz and Joshua D. Wright not participating. 

New Policy Statement

Following public comment on the two cases, the FTC decided to clarify language in the agency’s recently revised Green Guides for environmental marketing claims.

Paint and coating businesses must abide by the following three-part test to comply with 16 C.F.R. § 260.9(c).

“Depending on the context, a free-of or does-not-contain claim is appropriate even for a product, package, or service that contains or uses a trace amount of a substance if: (1) the level of the specified substance is no more than that which would be found as an acknowledged trace contaminant or background level; (2) the substance’s presence does not cause material harm that consumers typically associate with that substance;  and (3) the substance has not been added intentionally to the product.”

FTC headquarters
Carol M. Highsmith / Library of Congress

The cases prompted the FTC (above) to clarify language in its recently revised Green Guides for environmental marketing claims.

It is that first condition that the agency clarified with the new policy statement.

The "operative portion of the first prong of the FTC’s ‘trace test’ is ‘background level’ and not ‘acknowledged trace’ amount for VOCs in paint and coatings,” according to the FTC.

Thus, when companies market their paints and coatings as “free of” VOCs, they must comply with the first prong of the agency’s Green Guides’  trace test by demonstrating that “the level of the specified substance is no more than that which would be found” as a background level, and not the acknowledged trace amount.

The vote to issue the enforcement policy statement was 4-0-1, with Leibowitz not participating. 

Environmental Claims for Paint

“Environmental claims, like the VOC-free claims in this case, are very difficult, if not impossible, for consumers to confirm,” according to David Vladeck, director of FTC’s Bureau of Consumer Protection.

“That’s why it’s so important for the FTC to give clear guidance to marketers […] and to police the market to ensure that consumers actually get what they pay for.”

VOCs are carbon-containing compounds that easily evaporate at room temperatures. Some VOCs can be harmful to human health and the environment. Historically, interior paints have contained significant levels of VOCs.

Sherwin-Williams: New Practices

In an e-mailed statement, a Sherwin-Williams spokesman said the company had “reviewed its labeling and marketing information and is implementing the FTC's newly established practices.”

“Prior to the FTC's rejection of certain established industry practices for measuring VOC content, all S-W products, including Dutch Boy, followed the industry scientific testing practices for measuring VOCs,” according to Mike Conway, director of Corporate Communications & Investor Relations.

“S-W products previously complied and continue to comply with the strictest air quality regulations in the nation."

Conway added:  “There is no issue with S-W product quality or environmental factors.”

Sherwin-Williams customers may call 1-888-304-3769 or email questions@sherwin.com for more information.

The Cleveland-based coatings manufacturer is the largest in the U.S. and the third-largest in the world. Its brands include Sherwin-Williams, Dutch Boy, Krylon, Minwax, and Thompson’s WaterSeal.

PPG: Intends Full Compliance

PPG said it had been “working with the Federal Trade Commission to increase clarity regarding the marketing of low or zero-VOC paints, and PPG intends to comply fully with the consent order,” according to a statement by Jeremy Neuhart, the corporate public relations manager.

“PPG’s Pure Performance interior base paints do not contain VOCs, and as such PPG’s ‘zero VOC’ marketing claims for Pure Performance apply only to the base paints.

“Colorants added to base paint may result in finished products containing varying levels of VOCs, depending on the colorants used,” Neuhart noted.

A subsidiary of PPG Industries Inc., PPG Architectural Finishes Inc. does business under its own name, as well as under the names PPG, Pittsburgh Paints, Porter Paints, Pure Performance Paints and Olympic stain. The company is headquartered in Pittsburgh, PA.

   

Tagged categories: Coating chemistry; Federal Trade Commission; Government; Green coatings; Interior coatings; PPG; Sherwin-Williams; VOC content; VOC-free

Comment from Catherine Brooks, (3/8/2013, 9:52 AM)

This false advertising sound so familiar for S-W regarding DutchBoy paints. In the 1930's or so, they spent millions on advertising the benefits of new lead paint to brighten up people's homes. They went so far as to use the Dutch Boy s their primary spokesperson and distribute children's coloring books in their campaigns. It was not out of their ignorance of even the basic dangers of lead paint; Benjamin Franklin wrote about it centuries before! At the time of those marketing campaigns, the paint manufacturers probably did not know the vast extent of the neurological, developmental and irreversible side effects of tiny amounts of lead dust on children. Even today, scientists are connecting lead ingestion to violent behavior in children and teens. It continues to amaze me how large corporation jump on the bandwagons of the latest trends without telling their consumers the full truth of risks.


Comment Join the Conversation:

Sign in to our community to add your comments.

Advertisements
 
Novatek Corporation
 
Novatek Portable Air Filtration Systems
 
Air Scrubbers/Negative Air machines for restoration, abatement, dust & odor control, hazardous contaminant removal from job sites to clean rooms and hospitals. Portable, affordable!
 

 
Keim Mineral Coatings
 
Mineral Silicate Paints + Stains Fuse to Concrete
 
• Forms permanent chemical bonds
• Becomes part of the concrete
• Will never peel
• Looks completely natural
 

 
Shield Industries, Inc
 
FireGuard® E-84 Intumescent Coating - Shield Industries, Inc
 
Trust the certified protection of the industry’s most innovative intumescent coating FireGuard® E-84 to provide you with the 1 and 2 hour fire ratings you need.
 

 
 
 

Technology Publishing Co., 1501 Reedsdale Street, Suite 2008, Pittsburgh, PA 15233

TEL 1-412-431-8300  • FAX  1-412-431-5428  •  EMAIL webmaster@durabilityanddesign.com


The Technology Publishing Network

Durability + Design PaintSquare the Journal of Protective Coatings & Linings Paint BidTracker

 

© Copyright 2012-2018, Technology Publishing Co., All rights reserved