Durability + Design

Building Performance and Aesthetics

A Product of Technology Publishing
JPCL/PaintSquare | D+D | Paint BidTracker

Subscribe to D+D Magazine

Paint and Coatings Industry News

Main News Page


Dow Hit with $400M Jury Verdict

Monday, February 25, 2013

More items for Building Envelope

Comment | More

Dow Chemical Company conspired with other companies in a urethane price-fixing conspiracy and owes $400 million in damages to buyers affected, a federal jury in Kansas City, KS, has decided.

After a four-week trial, the jury returned its verdict Wednesday (Feb. 20) against the Michigan-based construction chemicals and coatings raw material producer, in a case that dates to 2005.

construction chemicals
www.dow.com

Dow Chemical, a worldwide producer of chemicals for building construction and other industries, has been fighting an eight-year-long lawsuit alleging a price-fixing conspiracy.

U.S. District Judge John W. Lungstrum has not yet issued an order on the seven-member jury’s verdict, but the final judgment could potentially be tripled under federal antitrust law.

5 Companies Implicated

The federal lawsuit alleged that Dow and its competitors—BASF SE, Bayer AG, Huntsman International LLC and Lyondell Chemical Company—began fixing prices for urethane by 1999, in violation of federal law. The conspiracy was said to have lasted into 2003.

Dow was the only remaining defendant; all of the other companies had settled out of court long ago, in agreements that topped $100 million in all.

The plaintiffs—buyers of urethane-based products for the construction, automotive, appliance and furniture industries—were seeking $1.125 billion in damages from Dow, according to court documents. The amount represented a 13 percent increase from what the prices would have been without the conspiracy, reports note.

“The people of Kansas have administered justice based on the evidence,” plaintiffs’ attorney Joseph Goldberg told members of the media after the verdict was read.

polyurethane foam
spraypolyurethane.org

Purchasers of urethane-based products said Dow officials conspired with competitors to fix prices from 1999 to 2003.

At trial, plaintiffs argued that Dow executives fixed prices with leaders of the other companies during phone calls, meetings at hotels, and on golf courses, reports said.

Appeal Considered

The company has denied the price-fixing allegations since the outset of the case. It said that prices were discussed, but that there was never an agreement to fix them, reports said, citing closing arguments in the case.

Dow did not respond to a request for comment Thursday (Feb. 21) evening from D+D News. However, Dow spokeswoman Rebecca Bentley told Bloomberg that the chemical company was disappointed that the jury had found price-fixing conduct during part of the five years alleged and was “evaluating all of our options, including appeal.”

David Bernick, an attorney for Dow, told Reuters that the company would seek to dismiss the lawsuit in a post-trial motion.

Past Settlements

The chemical companies were first sued in federal court in New Jersey in 2005, according to court documents. The case, In re: Urethane Antitrust Litigation, was then transferred to Kansas City that year as part of a multidistrict docket involving more than 60 plaintiffs.

In 2006, Bayer AG agreed to pay $55 million; Huntsman International LLC agreed to pay $33 million in 2011; and BASF Corp. agreed to pay $51 million in 2011. Lyondell Chemical Co. settled without paying damages because it was under bankruptcy protection. None of the companies that settled admitted any wrongdoing.

Plaintiffs Involved in Other Antitrust Litigation

Some of the plaintiff companies find themselves as defendants in another federal lawsuit in the U.S. District Court of Northern Ohio, where their customers alleged that they have conspired to fix, raise, maintain and/or stabilize prizes charged for polyurethane foam sold in the United States in violation of antitrust law.

That class action lawsuit is ongoing; however, the fairness of a $5 million settlement with one of the defendants, Vitafoam Inc., is currently set to be reviewed May 7.

   

Tagged categories: Construction chemicals; Dow Chemical Company; Insulation; Laws and litigation; Polyurethane; Spray polyurethane foam

Comment from John Fauth, (2/25/2013, 10:01 AM)

I'm at a loss to understand why Dow would risk litigating this case rather than settling for relatively little cost, and probably admitting no wrongdoing. Can someone enlighten me?


Comment from peter gibson, (2/25/2013, 10:50 AM)

Very simple answer... the greed factor. The big corporations have millions to spend on litigation.


Comment from John Fauth, (2/26/2013, 7:44 AM)

Peter, I have no doubt there's an element of greed in all successful companies. But I would think that same quality would cause Dow to be more judicious about the risks they willingly accept with that money once earned. On the face, it seems like an unacceptable risk/reward. I must be missing something.


Comment Join the Conversation:

Sign in to our community to add your comments.

Dow Chemical Company
FREE Webcast on Acrylic Roof Coatings

Learn about elastomeric roof coatings. Including: How roof coatings extend the useful life of a roof, save energy, are easy install, and cost effective!


BASF
New resins from BASF will have metals loving water:

Excellent corrosion resistance, low VOC, high gloss, thin films basf.us/industrialcoatings
polyorders@basf.com
800-231-7868


H&C Decorative Concrete Products
A comprehensive line for all your decorative concrete needs.

H&C® is committed to beautiful concrete protection and offers a variety of treatments and unlimited color possibilities.


SSPC: The Society for Protective Coatings
http://www.sspc.org/

Join SSPC and Enhance
Your Career !


Coatings For Industry, Inc.
For Tough Environments,
The Toughest Protection

A workplace exposed to vehicle traffic, fuel, and other harsh chemicals needs a floor coating that stands up to daily abuse. Wearcoat 100 high-build polyurethane provides superior protection.


Armakleen Company, The
No Ordinary Soda

ARMEX® baking soda-based abrasives from the makers of ARM & HAMMER® products offers over 12 formulas specially engineered for your application and your budget.


Westcoat
Bringing New Colors To Concrete Surfaces

Liven up your concrete surfaces with Westcoat's newest color choices. Introducing a myriad of Fast Stain, Liquid Dazzle, and Texture-Crete Interior colors.

 
 
 
Technology Publishing

The Technology Publishing Network

The Journal of Protective Coatings & Linings (JPCL) PaintSquare
Durability + Design Paint BidTracker JPCL Europe

 
EXPLORE D+D:      Interact   |   Blogs   |   Resources   |   Buying Guides   |   Webinars   |   White Papers   |   Classifieds
GET D+D:      Subscribe   |   Advertising Media Kit
KNOW D+D:      About D+D   |   Privacy policy   |   Terms & conditions   |   Site Map   |   Search   |   Contact Us
 

© Copyright 2010-2014, Technology Publishing, Co., All rights reserved
2100 Wharton Street, Suite 310, Pittsburgh PA 15203-1951; Tel 1-412-431-8300; Fax 1-412-431-5428; E-mail webmaster@paintsquare.com