Durability + Design
Follow us on Twitter Follow us on LinkedIn Like us on Facebook Follow us on Instagram Visit the TPC Store
Search the site

 

Advertisement

Durability + Design (D+D)


D+D News

Main News Page


Architect Wins Suit over Design Changes

Wednesday, January 30, 2013

More items for Color + Design

Comment | More

A museum architect’s intellectual-property rights were violated by an expansion project that altered his original design, a French court has ruled in awarding damages to the architect.

Henri Ciriani, 76, was awarded €30,000 (about $40,300) from a civil court in Marseille after the owners of the Arles Archaeological Museum added on to the structure in 2011 without his consent, according to a report in Building Design.

Altering Without Consent

The court said that the modern, triangular, ceramic-clad museum in Arles, France, was “well known” as the work of the architect and that Ciriani had a “right to be consulted about any alterations,” the report said.

Arles Archaelogical Museum
MM / Wikimedia Commons

Owners of the Archaeological Museum in Arles, France, will pay thousands to the architect who designed the building in 1984, after expanding the building in 2011 without his consent.

The rectilinear “box” addition, now near completion, makes room for a recently discovered Roman artifact, the report relates.

“It is clear from the evidence that the extension of the museum … was done without the consent and participation of Mr. Ciriani,” the report said, citing the court.

Ciriani, a French architect of Peruvian descent, designed the museum in 1984 and it opened in 1995.

Museum plan
www.arles-antique.cg13.fr

The original triangular shape of the museum has been altered with a rectilinear "box" in one of the structure's corners.

Evidence presented to the court indicated that the owners had attempted unsuccessfully to contact the architect before the expansion project, the report said. The architect said he found out about the construction after it had already begun.

The museum’s website celebrates the structure's triangular-shaped design, saying it “symbolically incarnates” the transmission and presentation of collections to the public.

Colleagues ‘Appalled’

Many members of the architectural community have spoken out against the addition and in favor of protecting the original design.

Henri Ciriani
Marcela777 / Wikimedia Commons

A colleague said Henri Ciriani was "extremely upset" after he found out about the addition to one of his works.

“It’s an appalling piece of work. It’s been done totally ineptly,” Allen Cunningham, former head of the University of Westminster’s School of Architecture and editor of The Journal of Architecture, told Building Design.

“Henri is extremely upset because it’s one of his major works and is a monument historique. What they’ve done destroys the harmony of the riverside facade."

The legal award is “a Pyrrhic victory," said Cunningham. "The money is a drop in the ocean to the [owners], so they probably think they’ve come out of it pretty well.”

The court did not order the addition torn down.

The French National Council of the Order of Architects, which gave evidence to the court “on behalf of the profession,” was also awarded €1,500 for expenses, according to the report.

Zaha Hadid Case in China

Chinese courts will also soon face the question of architects’ intellectual-property rights. Zaha Hadid Architects has filed suit against a Chinese developer for allegedly replicating one of the famed firm’s designs.

Developer Meiquan 22nd is constructing a building in Chongqing, China, that shares “distinctive round contours and white stripes of a 39-floor shopping and office complex conceived by the British-Iraqi designer and being built in Beijing,” according to a report in the New York Daily News.

The developer denies any wrongdoing; however, reports allude to the possibility that some digital files or renderings of Hadid’s project may have been snatched.

Such accusations "do not conform with the truth" and "have had a negative impact" on the company, Yao Yumao, general manager of Meiquan 22nd, reportedly said in a press conference.

To learn more about architects’ intellectual property and copyright of architectural works in the United States, the American Institute of Architects offers this information.

   

Tagged categories: Architecture; Building design; Design; Laws and litigation

Comment from Joseph Berchenko, (1/30/2013, 9:22 AM)

Architects in France have a “right to be consulted about any alterations” to a building they designed 30 years previously??? Wow.


Comment from Michael Bird, (1/30/2013, 11:26 AM)

Was Wright was consulted about the addition to the Guggenheim? This is great for Ciriani but doubt he would have been successful had it been in USA.


Comment Join the Conversation:

Sign in to our community to add your comments.

Advertisements
 
PPG Paints
 
NEW FORMULA! PPG PAINTS™ SEAL GRIP® PRIMER
 
PPG Paints Seal Grip Interior/Exterior Acrylic Universal Primer/Sealer has been reformulated to meet your toughest interior and exterior primer requirements.
VIEW PRODUCT
 

 
Atlas Material Testing Technology
 
Helping You Put Your Products To The Test
 
  • Outdoor Accelerated Weathering
  • Laboratory Testing Services
  • Accelerated Weathering Instruments

  • www.atlas-mts.com
    atlas.info@ametek.com
 

 
World of Concrete
 
WOC 2018 – Las Vegas, NV
 
Visit the WOC website for more details about the World of Concrete 2018: January 23-26; Seminars 22-26 at the Las Vegas Convention Center in Las Vegas, NV, USA.
 

 
RCI, Inc.
 
RCI Building Envelope Technology Symposium
 
November 13-14, 2017 | Orlando, Florida | Learn valuable design and repair insights from 20 leading design experts. RCI, Inc. is an AIA LU provider. Learn more.
 

 
Greenbuild
 
Greenbuild and ABX Together in Boston
 
Come to Boston and enjoy a 2 in 1 event! Greenbuild and ABX come together with over 700 exhibitors from the construction and design industry - register today!
 

 
A&I Coatings
 
Vitreflon – the hallmark of colour stable protective coatings
 
Vitreflon two pack fluoropolymer coatings display unsurpassed colour and gloss retention making Vitreflon the coating of choice for high value infrastructure and architecture. Contact us today to find out how Vitreflon can outperform on your next project. Vitreflon distributorships available.
 

 
LATICRETE International, Inc.
 
SPARTACOTE Flex PURE Clinical Plus Coatings
 
Equipped with antimicrobial technology, fast-cure systems and high-traction features. Ideal for demanding environments. Customizable colors and textures.
 

 
 
 

Technology Publishing Co., 1501 Reedsdale Street, Suite 2008, Pittsburgh, PA 15233

TEL 1-412-431-8300  • FAX  1-412-431-5428  •  EMAIL webmaster@durabilityanddesign.com


The Technology Publishing Network

Durability + Design PaintSquare the Journal of Protective Coatings & Linings Paint BidTracker

 

© Copyright 2012-2017, Technology Publishing Co., All rights reserved