Durability + Design
About  |  Subscribe  |  Advertise  |  Connect 
Follow us on Twitter Like us on Facebook


Download our free eBook on Fire Resistive Coating sponsored by Shield Industries Inc.

| More

Back to main blog page

About the Blogger


Blog Archives

Monday, May 21, 2012

Sorting out the Spin: Green ‘Grid’ Charts Sustainability Values

Perceptions of what constitutes a “green” coating are evolving, and it will take more than low and even zero VOC content to make the case for sustainability in architectural coatings as the definition of “green” morphs as well.

 cool roof coatings
“Cool-roof” coatings will remain a “win-win” sustainable technology, but “thermally responsive” coatings that change color could emerge to generate greater “green” buzz, Lux Research says in its new report, “Painting a Green Future.”

That’s a key message delivered by a newly issued study, “Painting a Green Future: Opportunities in Sustainable Architectural Coatings,” from Lux Research (Boston, Mass.).

The firm, noting that “greenwashing”—making claims about the environmental attributes of products that don’t stand up to objective scrutiny—can obscure the total environmental impact of materials, says it has developed a “Sustainability Grid” that gives a more complete and accurate picture of a technology’s sustainability profile.

This grid “defines sustainability along three dimensions—environmental impact, energy efficiency and resource efficiency—to create a simple ‘Sustainability Value,’” the firm said in announcing publication of the report.

Comparing this metric with technical value, Lux Research says its analysts “mapped out the technologies that will impact the architectural coatings market.”

“Sustainable coatings technologies reduce the energy, resource and environmental impact of paints and coatings, but often get confused with ‘greenwashed’ unsustainable alternatives,” Aditya Ranade, Lux Research analyst and lead author of the report, says in the firm’s announcement on the study’s publication.

“Sustainable coating technologies are moving beyond low volatile organic compound (VOC) content to include advances in additives like surfactants and coalescing agents, as well as energy-impacting coatings like cool roofs and even solar paints,” Ranade adds.

Winners and Pretenders?

Employing this Sustainability Grid, Lux Research says its analysts identified seven different technologies with “established” green credentials, including elastomeric cool roofs, low-e coatings and paint recycling. Those three types of materials and three others were judged to be “win-win” technologies, with the additional three “win-wins” identified as IR-reflective coatings, 100% solids powder coatings and enhanced hiding-power coatings.

 Sustainability Grid
The “Sustainability Grid” offers an assessment of existing and emerging technologies, based on sustainability and technical value.

The grid also purports to assess the potential sustainability and technical value of a number of “Emerging Green” technologies, such as solar-energy paint, bio-based materials, UV-cure coatings, self-healing coatings, photocatalytic coatings, and others (see accompanying figure).

Using this Sustainability Grid, Lux Research also categorized various technologies as “Endangered,” “Survivors” and the decidedly less provocative “Voluntary Adoption.”

Ranade, the lead analyst and report author, said in an interview with D+D that “win-win” technologies “offer both technology and sustainability value.” The other categories are described as follows.

• Voluntary Adoption” technologies offer significant sustainability value but are compromised on either performance or cost.

• “Endangered” technologies have negative sustainability impact and questionable technology value.

• “Survivor” technologies will provide enough technical value to the end users and developers to fight rising regulations

Ranade cited “responsive” cool roofs as an example of a “future winner.”

“Thermally responsive coatings that turn from white to black, such as those from Creative Material Technologies and Thermeleon, are set to expand the geographic footprint of cool roofs,” Ranade said. “The technology is years away from becoming mainstream, but has high potential.”

“Traditional cool roofs reduce solar heat gain, thereby reducing air-conditioning loads during summer, but also increase heating loads during winter. According to a 2003 study by the EPA, northern cities such as Chicago show barely above-zero net savings. But New York City shows net savings of 10% to 20% due to high electricity prices in summer, and California shows the greatest net savings of 30% to 40% in cooling costs.”

A “temperature-sensitive” material that is white in summer (i.e. reflecting solar radiation in summer) and “black” in winter (i.e. absorbing solar radiation during winter) “will greatly expand the geographical reach of cool roofs,” he said.

By contrast, solar paints—another “emerging” technology—don’t land in the “win-win” space in the report’s Sustainability Grid, and are “still a long shot,” Lux Research says.

“Several new technologies enable ‘spraying’ of solar cell coatings on buildings, but they suffer from very low (2%) efficiency relative to incumbent solar PV (13% to 15%) and most still remain in labs,” the firm says.

Ranade says these challenges mean “that this is likely to remain a nice curiosity. Most solar paints remain in the laboratories like University of Notre Dame, although a few very early-stage start-ups such as NextGen Solar have emerged in 2011.”

For those interested in shopping for more about Lux Research’s picks for green “winners” and those that are more likely to wither (or at least fade), here’s where to go: www.luxresearchinc.com.

I guess we can get used to roofs changing color, but I was really charged up about paint that turns sunlight into electricity and am a bit disappointed it’s not a sure “win-win.” It loses some of its voltage by being relegated to the “voluntary adoption” zone.

More items for Coatings Technology

Tagged categories: Cool roof coatings; Roof coatings

Comment from Tom Schwerdt, (6/11/2012, 4:18 PM)

Solar paint is a neat concept, but I think that niche will be filled by laminating or adhering thin-film solar, which has already reached 17% cell efficiency in the lab (equivalent conditions to the "solar paint" reaching 2%.) Available in-production modules are more like 12% efficiency.

Comment Join the Conversation:

Sign in to our community to add your comments.

PPG Protective and Marine Coatings Group
Industrial strength performance in ONE can.

Now get the durability and protection of two components in one can: Amercoat® ONE, PSX® ONE and Sigmadur ONE.

Dumond Chemicals Inc.
Peel Away®1 Heavy Duty Paint Remover

has been the #1 Choice of Professionals who perform Historic Restoration and Lead Paint Abatement for over 25 years. Peel Away®1 is an eco-safe method for removing up to 30 Coats of oil-based lead paints in a single application.

Atlas Material Testing Technology

Helping You Put Your Products To The Test

• Outdoor Accelerated
• Laboratory Testing
• Accelerated Weathering

www.atlas-mts.com atlas.info@ametek.com

Keim Mineral Coatings
Translucent concrete stains for new and old concrete

Penetrating, translucent mineral silicate stains harmonize uneven concrete color and blend patches and repairs, without the "painted" look. Will never peel.

SSPC: The Society for Protective Coatings
SSPC 2016 Register Now!

SSPC2016 is earlier this year, don't forget to book your plane tickets and hotel. See you soon. For more information visit www.sspc2016.com

Beautiful Wood, NO flames

Achieve a Class A flame spread rating on your fine wood products with a clear, varnish-quality, durable finish. PyroCide Clear by PyroTech

AGC Chemicals
FEVE Coating Simulates Dazzling Gold Leaf On Facade Restoration

LUMIFLON based coatings can last up to 30 years without fading, offering a low-maintenance solution that retains color and gloss and can be field-applied

KTA-Tator, Inc. - Corporate Office
KTA Inspection Services

Determine Specification Compliance:
• Surface Preparation
• Moisture Content
• Paint Materials & Application
• Aesthetics
Contact: Kevin Brown,


Technology Publishing Co., 2100 Wharton Street, Suite 310, Pittsburgh PA 15203-1951

TEL 1-412-431-8300  • FAX  1-412-431-5428  •  EMAIL webmaster@durabilityanddesign.com

The Technology Publishing Network

Durability + Design PaintSquare the Journal of Protective Coatings & Linings Paint BidTracker


© Copyright 2012-2015, Technology Publishing Co., All rights reserved